Edward III: from the Scottish border to Poitou · no. 3
Crécy
The editors’ headings put the third act’s battle scenes in Picardy, in fields near Cressi. The battle was fought on 26 August 1346; the ground is disputed.
- Dates
- 26 August 1346
- Where
- Crécy-en-Ponthieu, Somme
- Position
- 50.2564° N, 1.8878° E. The position given for the battle in the infobox of Wikipedia’s article (50°15′23″N 1°53′16″E), on the traditional site beside Crécy-en-Ponthieu. I read it in a search extract of a copy and could not re-open the article, so treat the figure as provisional. Michael Livingston argues that the fighting was nearer the Forest of Crécy, to the south, so the exact ground is not settled.5
- Plays
- Edward III
What the play says
The editors’ heading for the second scene of the third act is ‘Picardy. Fields near Cressi’, and four further scenes in that act are headed ‘The same’.6 The spelling is Cressi, and the battle is also written Cressy in English.7 The play’s first scene of that act is headed ‘Flanders. The French Camp’, which this map does not pin. I did not read the play, and I do not reproduce its text.
What the documents and the ground show
The battle was fought on 26 August 1346 near Crécy in northern France, between Philip VI and Edward III, and is counted the first of the three great English successes of the war, with Poitiers and Agincourt.8
Where, exactly, is disputed. The traditional site is on the north-west side of the town of Crécy-en-Ponthieu, and goes back to at least 1757.9 Michael Livingston argues that the sources point instead to high ground beside the Forest of Crécy, south of the town on the road to Abbeville, more than 5 km from the traditional site; he says he is about 90 per cent sure of that and 99 per cent sure the traditional one is wrong, and the publisher’s blog adds that without archaeology it cannot be known for certain.1011
The point is uncertain. It is on the traditional site, the position in the infobox of Wikipedia’s article, which I read only as a search extract of a copy; at this map’s scale the two candidate sites are about a marker’s width apart, so the marker stands for the area.12
Tradition, inference and open questions
The play puts the battle in the third act and moves on to Calais in the fourth, and my reading of the headings is that its order does not follow the dates, because the fourth act’s long sequence at Poitiers is of 1356, ten years later.13 That is an inference from the headings, not from a reading of the scenes.
Open questions: the true site, and how the dramatist used the chronicle accounts. The English camp that follows is at Calais.
Notes
- Encyclopædia Britannica, eleventh edition (1911), ‘Crécy’, as posted on Wikisource, the two wings. Source ↓ ↩
- World History Encyclopedia, ‘Battle of Crécy’, the divisions and the slope. Source ↓ ↩
- Longbow Archers, ‘Crécy, 26 August 1346’, the valley and the river. Source ↓ ↩
- ‘The Battle of Crécy’, magazine article, excerpt on Everand, the mill and the road from Abbeville. Source ↓ ↩
- Wikipedia, ‘Battle of Crécy’. Source ↓ ↩
- King Edward III, Project Gutenberg ebook 1770, contents and scene headings. Source ↓ ↩
- Wikipedia, Battle of Crécy, the battle and its place. Source ↓ ↩
- Wikipedia, Battle of Crécy, the battle and its place. Source ↓ ↩
- Medievalists.net, ‘New location for the Battle of Crécy discovered’, Livingston on the site. Source ↓ ↩
- Medievalists.net, location of Crécy, Livingston on the site. Source ↓ ↩
- Liverpool University Press blog, ‘The Battle of Crécy: new discoveries overturn centuries of scholarship’, the proposed site. Source ↓ ↩
- Wikipedia, Battle of Crécy, the battle and its place. Source ↓ ↩
- Gutenberg, Edward III (scene headings), contents and scene headings. Source ↓ ↩
Sources cited
- Secondary · Reference Encyclopædia Britannica, eleventh edition (1911), ‘Crécy’, as posted on Wikisource — read the entry Only a search extract was read. Only a search extract was read, on a mirror of the Wikisource text. It says the English lay on the forward slope of a hillside with their right in front of the village of Crécy and their left resting on Wadicourt. Used for which end of the ridge each wing held.
- Secondary · Reference World History Encyclopedia, ‘Battle of Crécy’ — read the article Only a search extract was read. Only a search extract was read. It says Edward’s force was in three divisions, with the flanks protected on one side by a forest and marshy ground and on the other by the village of Wadicourt, so the French had to narrow their lines and attack uphill. Used for the three divisions and the slope.
- Secondary · Amateur Longbow Archers, ‘Crécy, 26 August 1346’ — read the page Only a search extract was read. Only a search extract was read. It says the English were aligned on a ridge between Crécy and Wadicourt, that the ground in front slopes away to a shallow valley with a small river, and that the ridge is steepest towards Crécy and softer and marshy at the bottom towards Wadicourt. A hobby site; used for the valley and the river.
- Secondary · Reference ‘The Battle of Crécy’, magazine article, excerpt on Everand — read the excerpt Only a search extract was read. Only a search extract was read. It says a ridge between Wadicourt and Crécy sloped down to the River Maye just over a mile away, that at the foot lay a valley and the main road from Abbeville along which the French would advance, and that a windmill at the top became Edward’s command post. Used for the mill, the valley and the French approach.
- Secondary · Wikipedia Wikipedia, ‘Battle of Crécy’ — the battle and its place Only a search extract was read. Only search extracts of the article and copies were seen; the article could not be re-opened. They give the battle as fought on 26 August 1346 near Crécy in northern France between Philip VI and Edward III, and as occasionally written ‘Cressy’ in English, and as the first of the three major English successes of the Hundred Years’ War, with Poitiers and Agincourt. The grid position used on this site (50°15′23″N 1°53′16″E) was read from the infobox of a copy.
- Secondary · Reference King Edward III, Project Gutenberg ebook 1770 — contents and scene headings Only a search extract was read. A public-domain etext, listed as by a dubious author. Only search extracts were seen, not the play. They give the setting as ‘dispers’d; in England, Flanders, and France’ and the first scenes as ‘London. A Room of State in the Palace’ and ‘Roxborough. Before the Castle’. Another extract of the contents continues: ‘The Same. Gardens of the Castle’ and ‘A Room in the Castle’ (Act 2), ‘Flanders. The French Camp’, ‘Picardy. Fields near Cressi’ and four scenes headed ‘The same’ (Act 3), ‘Bretagne. Camp of the English’, ‘Picardy. The English Camp before Calais’ and ‘Poitou. Fields near Poitiers’ with its camps and field of battle (Act 4).
- Secondary · News Medievalists.net, ‘New location for the Battle of Crécy discovered’ — Livingston on the site Only a search extract was read. A news report. Only a search extract was seen. It says the traditional site dates to at least 1757, on the north-west side of the town; that Michael Livingston, in The Battle of Crécy: A Casebook, proposes a site by the Forest of Crécy, south of the town; and that he is about 90 per cent sure of the alternative and 99 per cent sure the traditional one is wrong.
- Secondary · Reference Liverpool University Press blog, ‘The Battle of Crécy: new discoveries overturn centuries of scholarship’ — the proposed site Only a search extract was read. A publisher’s blog by Michael Livingston. Only a search extract was seen. It says the traditional site is more than 5 km from the most likely location, which lies south of Crécy-en-Ponthieu beside the Forest of Crécy, on the high ground of the road between Crécy and Abbeville, and that without archaeological investigation it cannot be known for certain.