Where did Shakespeare set each kind of play? This page counts the places on the maps and looks for a shape. It is a count of the site’s own points, not a reading of the plays.
Drawn from map data Every setting on the play maps, by kind of play. One dot for each place that a play map pins, at the position its map uses, coloured by the kind of play. A place that serves plays of more than one kind has one dot for each, side by side, and a bigger dot means more plays. Places that are not settings (playhouses, Stratford, the reference points) are left out. The coastline is Natural Earth (public domain) at a coarse scale, and north is at the top. The scale bar is exact from north to south but from east to west only along 44° N. A position is only as exact as its page says.
What this shows
Every map on the site pins the places its play names, where they can be placed. Taken together, the maps for the 39 plays that have one pin 99 different places, 124 pairings of a play with a place. Sorting the plays by kind and looking at where their places fall gives four different pictures, set out below with the numbers that carry them. Each play counts once, however many places it has, so a play with a dozen named towns does not outweigh one set in a single palace.
The kinds are the First Folio’s comedies, histories and tragedies, with Edward III among the histories, and the five romances as the site groups them: Pericles, Cymbeline, The Winter’s Tale, The Tempest and The Two Noble Kinsmen. That sorting is mine and it is open to argument. The last section says what the count leaves out.
Histories: one continuous country
Ten of the 11 histories have a setting in England or Wales; the eleventh, Edward III, is set on the Scottish border and in France. Across all of them, 79% of the settings are in Britain and 21% in France, and none is anywhere else. The farthest a history reaches from London is 740 km.
The places the histories use form a single chain. 47 of the 50 can be joined, one to the next, in steps of no more than 120 km, across Britain and into northern France. For the tragedies the figure is 8 of 26, for the comedies 4 of 16 and for the romances 2 of 15. They are also the plays set in London: Henry V (at Blackheath), Henry VI Parts 1 and 2, Henry VIII and Richard III each have a setting within 15 km of it. Among the other 28 plays only Cymbeline does, through Lud’s Town, which editors identify with London; The Merry Wives of Windsor is the nearest comedy, about 36 km away.
Comedies: Italian cities, and inland
5 of the 12 comedies have an Italian setting, and four of them (The Merchant of Venice, The Taming of the Shrew, The Two Gentlemen of Verona and All’s Well That Ends Well) fall in the one cluster of northern Italian places around Venice, Verona, Padua and Florence. The others are set in France and Navarre (Love’s Labour’s Lost, All’s Well), the Greek and Aegean world (A Midsummer Night’s Dream, The Comedy of Errors), Vienna (Measure for Measure) and the invented Illyria (Twelfth Night). Only two comedies are set in England, at Windsor and in the Forest of Arden, and neither is in London.
The comedies are also the inland plays. Six of the twelve (The Two Gentlemen of Verona, All’s Well, Love’s Labour’s Lost, Measure for Measure, The Merry Wives and As You Like It) have most of their settings more than 50 km from the sea. Of the other 27 plays only one, Romeo and Juliet, does (Fisher’s exact test, p = 0.002). Most comedies are also compact: eleven of the twelve stay within 500 km, and most keep to a single place.
Tragedies: Rome and the Aegean, and a few in the north
The tragedies put 44% of their settings in Italy and 23% in Greece and the Aegean. Rome alone is pinned for four of them (Titus Andronicus, Julius Caesar, Coriolanus and Antony and Cleopatra). Four have a Greek or Aegean setting (Julius Caesar at Philippi, Antony and Cleopatra, Timon of Athens, Troilus and Cressida) and two reach the Levant or North Africa (Alexandria, and Cyprus for Othello).
The exceptions form a small northern group of three: Macbeth in Scotland, King Lear at Dover, and Hamlet at Elsinore. Like the romances, the tragedies are set almost wholly near the sea: only 9% of their settings are more than 50 km inland, and the one tragedy that is mostly inland is Romeo and Juliet, at Verona.
Romances: the coasts and the voyages
The romances are the kind that travels. Four of the five span more than 500 km, and their median spread is 1,360 km; one comedy does so (All’s Well, about 890 km), three tragedies (Julius Caesar, Antony and Cleopatra, Othello) and four histories (Edward III, Henry VI Parts 1 and 3, and King John). They are also the plays set farthest from London, 1,830 km on average against 190 km for the histories.
They are the only kind with a real share of settings in the Levant and North Africa, 23%: Tyre, Tarsus, Antioch and Pentapolis for Pericles, and Tunis for The Tempest. Their settings are mostly ports and coasts (only 10% are more than 50 km inland), joined by sea voyages the maps do not draw.
Places that more than one kind shares
Only 7 places carry plays of more than one kind: Athens and the wood, Dover, Ephesus, Messina, Rome, Venice and Verona. Venice, Verona and Messina each hold both a comedy and a tragedy; Rome holds tragedies and a romance, and Athens all three of tragedy, comedy and romance. The histories share with the others only Dover, with King Lear; Ephesus holds The Comedy of Errors and Pericles. Places are counted by place page, so Paris, which has one page for All’s Well and another for Henry VI, Part 1, is not among them. The ties that shared places make between plays are counted on Movement and ties.
How far from London
Counted from the list How far from London each play is set. One dot for each play, at the average straight-line distance of its pinned settings from the middle of London, in rounded kilometres. The upright line is the median for that kind of play. Counted from the site’s own map data; hover over a dot for the play and its figure.
The histories sit apart. Measured by the average distance of a play’s settings from London, the histories differ from each of the other three kinds with p no higher than 0.003 (Mann–Whitney). The tragedies, comedies and romances cannot be told apart this way (p between 0.279 and 0.538): what separates them is where they go and how they travel, not how far away they are.
How far from the sea, pin by pin
The sections above say how many settings of each kind are more than 50 km inland. This one gives the distance itself for every pin: the straight line from each marker to the nearest coast on the Natural Earth outline the maps use, with one dot for each play-place pair.
Counted from the list How far from the sea each pinned setting is, by kind of play. One dot for each play-place pair, at the straight-line distance in kilometres from the marker to the nearest coast on the Natural Earth 1:50m outline, on a square-root scale so that the few far inland pins fit. The upright line is the median for that kind of play. Counted from the site’s own map data; hover over a dot for the play, the place and the figure.
The medians are 11 km for the tragedies and 10 km for the romances, 37 km for the histories and 65 km for the comedies. Of the 99 places pinned on the play maps, 21 are within 5 km of the sea and 22 are more than 50 km from it. 9 of the 17 comedy pairs are beyond 50 km, against 1 of 32 for the tragedies (Verona, for Romeo and Juliet) and 1 of 15 for the romances (Bohemia). The histories reach 14 of 60, but Britain is narrow: no British pin is farther from the sea than Bosworth Field, at 105 km, so the histories’ inland places are the middle of England and the Loire towns of France.
The farthest pin of all is Bohemia, at 415 km, and it is the only one of the 22 whose place page, where it says what the play does, mentions a coast. Next come Vienna, Orléans and Amboise. The 22 pins more than 50 km from the sea are:
Places pinned on the play maps that are more than 50 km from the sea, with the plays and how sure the position is
This measures where the pins are, not what the plays do. A pin 100 km inland says nothing about whether a play puts a ship there, and the pages record what the editors’ headings name, not how the characters get to a place. Milan and Verona sit about 120 and 100 km inland; the Milan page notes that a study guide finds the play inconsistent about which scenes are in Milan or Verona, and does not say what the play does with the sea. A river port such as Orléans, Amboise or Paris is inland by this measure though a boat can reach it. The coast is today’s coarse Natural Earth line, so it shows direction better than exact kilometres. I did not read the plays. The cases where my pages record a play parting from the ground are gathered on Plays and the record.
By region
Counted from the list Where each kind of play is set, by region. Each play counts once, shared out equally among its pinned places, so a play with many places does not outweigh one with few. The regions are my grouping of the places, and the shares are of the plays of that kind. Counted from the site’s own map data.
The same picture by region. The histories are almost wholly Britain and France; the tragedies lean on Italy and the Greek world; the comedies spread across Italy, France, Greece and Britain; the romances are the only kind that reaches into the Levant and North Africa.
The clusters
Grouping the 99 places by distance (average linkage on great-circle distance, cut at 200 km) gives 27 clusters, 11 of them with more than one place. The others are single places such as Elsinore, Alexandria or Vienna.
The clusters of places, with the number of plays of each kind set in each
Cluster
Places
Histories
Tragedies
Comedies
Romances
South-east England and the Channel coast
25
9
1
1
1
The Midlands, the Marches and the North
18
7
0
1
0
Scotland and the Border
10
3
1
0
0
Rome and Campania
7
0
4
0
2
Northern Italy
5
0
2
4
0
Normandy and Paris
4
2
0
1
0
The Loire and Poitou
4
4
0
0
0
Attica and Boeotia
3
0
2
1
1
The coast of Anatolia
3
0
1
1
1
Cilicia and Antioch
2
0
0
0
1
Sicily
2
0
1
1
1
The two English clusters are almost all histories; Rome and Campania is tragedy with two romances (Cymbeline and The Tempest); northern Italy is comedy with two tragedies (Romeo and Juliet and Othello). A play can appear in more than one cluster, so the rows do not add up to the number of plays.
The plays one by one
‘Mostly in’ is the region with the largest share of the play’s places. ‘From London’ is the average distance of the play’s settings, and ‘Spread’ is the distance between its two farthest settings, both in a straight line and rounded to 10 km.
The plays, by kind, with the number of places pinned, the region they are mostly in, and their distances
Play
Kind
Places
Mostly in
From London, km
Spread, km
Edward III
History
4
France and Navarre
350
1,030
Henry IV, Part 1
History
5
England, Wales and Scotland
270
460
Henry IV, Part 2
History
2
England, Wales and Scotland
360
150
Henry V
History
6
France and Navarre
150
250
Henry VI, Part 1
History
8
France and Navarre
280
740
Henry VI, Part 2
History
9
England, Wales and Scotland
30
130
Henry VI, Part 3
History
6
England, Wales and Scotland
230
730
Henry VIII
History
3
England, Wales and Scotland
30
90
King John
History
4
England, Wales and Scotland
200
610
Richard II
History
6
England, Wales and Scotland
210
300
Richard III
History
7
England, Wales and Scotland
40
150
Antony and Cleopatra
Tragedy
6
Italy and Sicily
2,140
1,960
Coriolanus
Tragedy
3
Italy and Sicily
1,430
0
Hamlet
Tragedy
1
Elsewhere
970
0
Julius Caesar
Tragedy
6
Italy and Sicily
1,560
990
King Lear
Tragedy
1
England, Wales and Scotland
110
0
Macbeth
Tragedy
8
England, Wales and Scotland
640
150
Othello
Tragedy
2
The Levant and North Africa
2,200
2,150
Romeo and Juliet
Tragedy
1
Italy and Sicily
1,060
0
Timon of Athens
Tragedy
2
Greece and the Aegean
2,390
0
Titus Andronicus
Tragedy
1
Italy and Sicily
1,430
0
Troilus and Cressida
Tragedy
1
Greece and the Aegean
2,390
0
A Midsummer Night’s Dream
Comedy
1
Greece and the Aegean
2,390
0
All’s Well That Ends Well
Comedy
3
France and Navarre
850
890
As You Like It
Comedy
1
England, Wales and Scotland
140
0
Love’s Labour’s Lost
Comedy
1
France and Navarre
970
0
Measure for Measure
Comedy
1
Elsewhere
1,230
0
Much Ado About Nothing
Comedy
1
Italy and Sicily
1,920
0
The Comedy of Errors
Comedy
1
Greece and the Aegean
2,620
0
The Merchant of Venice
Comedy
2
Italy and Sicily
1,120
20
The Merry Wives of Windsor
Comedy
1
England, Wales and Scotland
40
0
The Taming of the Shrew
Comedy
2
Italy and Sicily
1,080
70
The Two Gentlemen of Verona
Comedy
2
Italy and Sicily
1,010
140
Twelfth Night
Comedy
1
Elsewhere
1,660
0
Cymbeline
Romance
3
England, Wales and Scotland
590
1,720
Pericles, Prince of Tyre
Romance
6
The Levant and North Africa
2,970
1,360
The Tempest
Romance
2
Italy and Sicily
1,720
570
The Two Noble Kinsmen
Romance
2
Greece and the Aegean
2,360
50
The Winter’s Tale
Romance
2
Italy and Sicily
1,490
1,370
How this was made, and what it leaves out
What is counted. The places pinned on the play maps. Settings the maps do not pin (rooms, camps, plains, heaths, the sea) are not in it, so a play whose named places can be found weighs more than one set in rooms. London’s playhouses, Shakespeare in London, Stratford, Warwickshire and the marriage of 1582 are not about a play’s setting and are left out, as are the reference points flagged ‘Not in the play’. A place pinned on several maps counts for each play it serves, so Dover is counted for King Lear, Henry V and Henry VI, Part 2.
What the places rest on. The positions are the maps’: a town stands for a place, and many are only approximate or uncertain, as each place page says. The settings come from the editors’ headings and synopses cited on those pages. I did not read the plays.
The sorting. Kinds follow the First Folio, except that the romances are the site’s group. Cymbeline is a tragedy in the Folio, and Measure for Measure and All’s Well are sometimes called problem plays; moving them would change some numbers and would not change the main contrasts. Edward III and The Two Noble Kinsmen are not in the Folio, and I placed them with the histories and the romances.
Distances and clusters. Straight lines on the globe from London’s centre. Clusters are average-linkage groups cut at 200 km; a different cut would merge or split some. Distance from the sea uses the site’s coarse Natural Earth coast, so it shows direction better than exact kilometres.
The tests. Kruskal–Wallis and Mann–Whitney tests on the 39 plays’ average distances and Fisher’s exact test on counts. With so few plays, and several comparisons not corrected for one another, the p-values are guides to which contrasts are large, not proofs.
What it cannot show. Why a play is set where it is. Part of the pattern may come from the sources the maps use for each play, and the count cannot separate that from Shakespeare’s choices. It does not measure when a play is set, and it counts places, not scenes or lines.
The coast section is made by python3 tools/gencoast.py <site folder> <ne_50m_land.geojson> (numpy, and the Natural Earth land file, whose address is at the top of the script), which writes inc/coast-data.php and the figure patterns-coast. The pairs and the kinds are the ones above.
Remaking it.python3 tools/genpatterns.py <site folder> redraws the three figures and rewrites the tables from data/*.geojson. If a map gains or loses a place, run it again and check this text against the new numbers.
The figures are drawn from the site’s own data; the coastline is Natural Earth, in the public domain.