Movement and ties
Two counts of the same data. Which plays are set in the same places as other plays, and how far the headings of a few plays carry you from one place to the next. Both count the site’s own points; neither is a reading of the plays.
Plays that share a place
The play maps pin 99 places, 124 pairings of a play with a place, across 39 plays (the same count as Patterns). 82 of the places serve one play. The other 17 serve more than one, and the figure shows them: a dot where a play is set in a place, with the plays that share nothing left out. Rome serves five plays, Athens four, Dover, the Tower of London and Verona three each, and the other twelve places two.
| Place | Plays | Kinds |
|---|---|---|
| Rome | Antony and Cleopatra, Coriolanus, Julius Caesar, Titus Andronicus and Cymbeline | tragedy, romance |
| Athens and the wood | Antony and Cleopatra, Timon of Athens, A Midsummer Night’s Dream and The Two Noble Kinsmen | tragedy, comedy, romance |
| Dover | Henry V, Henry VI, Part 2 and King Lear | history, tragedy |
| Tower of London | Henry VI, Part 1, Henry VI, Part 2 and Richard III | history |
| Verona | Romeo and Juliet, The Taming of the Shrew and The Two Gentlemen of Verona | tragedy, comedy |
| Angers | Henry VI, Part 1 and King John | history |
| Blackheath | Henry V and Henry VI, Part 2 | history |
| Capitol | Coriolanus and Julius Caesar | tragedy |
| Ephesus | The Comedy of Errors and Pericles, Prince of Tyre | comedy, romance |
| Forum and Rostra | Coriolanus and Julius Caesar | tragedy |
| Gaultree Forest | Henry IV, Part 1 and Henry IV, Part 2 | history |
| Messina | Antony and Cleopatra and Much Ado About Nothing | tragedy, comedy |
| Rouen | Henry V and Henry VI, Part 1 | history |
| Tewkesbury | Henry VI, Part 3 and Richard III | history |
| Venice | Othello and The Merchant of Venice | tragedy, comedy |
| Warkworth Castle | Henry IV, Part 1 and Henry IV, Part 2 | history |
| Westminster Abbey | Henry VI, Part 1 and Richard III | history |
Seven of the shared places cross kinds of play (Rome, Athens and the wood, Dover, Verona, Ephesus, Messina, Venice); the other ten serve plays of one kind. Counting each pair of plays that share at least one place, there are 32 such pairs, 16 within one kind and 16 across two. A place is a shared one only if its page is the same page: Paris has one page for All’s Well That Ends Well and another for Henry VI, Part 1, so it is not in this table, and the section on nearness below puts that right.
Groups, and plays on their own
Joining plays that share a place, the 39 plays fall into 6 groups of two or more and 14 plays that share no place with any other.
- A group of 9. Antony and Cleopatra, Coriolanus, Julius Caesar, Timon of Athens, Titus Andronicus, A Midsummer Night’s Dream, Much Ado About Nothing, Cymbeline and The Two Noble Kinsmen. It is held together by Rome and Athens: Rome ties the four Roman plays to Cymbeline, Athens ties Timon of Athens, A Midsummer Night’s Dream and The Two Noble Kinsmen to Antony and Cleopatra, and Messina ties Much Ado About Nothing to the same play. It holds plays of three kinds: tragedies, comedies and romances.
- A group of 7. Henry V, Henry VI, Part 1, Henry VI, Part 2, Henry VI, Part 3, King John, Richard III and King Lear. It is the histories of the English crown and France, joined to King Lear by Dover.
- Smaller groups. Romeo and Juliet, The Taming of the Shrew and The Two Gentlemen of Verona share Verona; Henry IV, Part 1 and Henry IV, Part 2 share Warkworth Castle and Gaultree Forest; Othello and The Merchant of Venice share Venice; and The Comedy of Errors and Pericles, Prince of Tyre share Ephesus.
The 14 plays on their own are All’s Well That Ends Well, As You Like It, Edward III, Hamlet, Henry VIII, Love’s Labour’s Lost, Macbeth, Measure for Measure, Richard II, The Merry Wives of Windsor, The Tempest, The Winter’s Tale, Troilus and Cressida and Twelfth Night. By kind, 6 of the 12 comedies, 3 of the 11 histories, 3 of the 11 tragedies and 2 of the 5 romances share no place. Four pairs of plays share more than one: Coriolanus and Julius Caesar (3: Capitol, Forum and Rostra, Rome); Henry IV, Part 1 and Henry IV, Part 2 (2: Gaultree Forest, Warkworth Castle); Henry V and Henry VI, Part 2 (2: Blackheath, Dover); Henry VI, Part 1 and Richard III (2: Tower of London, Westminster Abbey). Antony and Cleopatra has the most ties, with 8 other plays, because it is set in Rome, Athens and Messina, each of which another play also uses.
If nearby counts as shared
Sharing a place page is a strict test, because the site splits some places across pages: Rome has a page for the city and four more for its Forum, Capitol, Caesar’s pyre and Pompey’s curia, there are two pages for Athens and two for Paris, and London’s settings are a dozen or so pages within a few kilometres of each other. If two places within 10 km of each other count as the same, the groups change: 18 plays form one group, and only 12 plays are on their own. The group takes in the histories set in London (Henry V at Blackheath, Henry VI, Richard III, Henry VIII), Cymbeline through Lud’s Town, and All’s Well That Ends Well through Paris. Because Cymbeline is set in Rome as well as in Lud’s Town, it joins the Roman group to the English one. The four smaller groups stay as they were.
The two counts bracket the answer. A shared page is the lower bound and the 10 km rule is the upper one, and the difference is mostly London, Rome and Paris.
How far the headings travel
Some maps number their places in the order the plays’ headings reach them: the history maps and the map for Pericles. Joining the places in that order, in straight lines, gives the length of the route the headings imply. The longest is Pericles at 2,982 km, about twice the next, and the shortest is Henry VIII, 91 km, because two of its three places are in London and the third is about 89 km from them. Among the histories, France, Henry V to Henry VI is longest at 1,503 km, with a single leap from Paris to Bordeaux of 499 km. The longest leg on any map is Tarsus to Pentapolis in Pericles, 1,271 km, all of it across the sea.
The comedy and tragedy maps are numbered by region, not by scene, so they have no route. A map is not always a play: the Wars of the Roses map joins places from Henry VI, Parts 2 and 3 and Richard III in the order of the record, and the France map joins Henry V to Henry VI, Part 1 and the one place from Part 3. A route here is a measure of how widely a map is spread in the order its places are numbered, and it does not say where a scene moved.
How fast the record moved
Where the place pages give an exact date for two places and one force went from one to the other in under two months, the straight-line distance over the days gives a pace. There are seven such legs, and the paces run from 2.5 to 8.7 km a day. They are a floor, not a marching rate: the force did not go in a straight line, it halted, besieged, fought and waited, and the dates are those of events, not of departures.
| Leg | Who | From, to | Straight line | Days | Km a day |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Crécy to Calais | Edward III’s army | 26 August 1346, 4 September 1346 (the battle to the start of the siege) | 78 km | 9 | 8.7 |
| Barnet to Tewkesbury | Edward IV’s army | 14 April 1471, 4 May 1471 (battle to battle) | 140 km | 20 | 7.0 |
| Southwark to Iden’s garden | Cade | 1 July 1450, 12 July 1450 (the arrival to Cade’s wounding) | 73 km | 11 | 6.6 |
| Agincourt to Blackheath | Henry V and his party | 25 October 1415, 23 November 1415 (the battle to the return) | 186 km | 29 | 6.4 |
| Harfleur to Agincourt | Henry V’s army | 22 September 1415, 25 October 1415 (the end of the siege to the battle) | 174 km | 33 | 5.3 |
| Mortimer’s Cross to Towton | Edward’s army | 2 February 1461, 29 March 1461 (battle to battle) | 205 km | 55 | 3.7 |
| Solefields, Sevenoaks to Southwark | Cade’s host | 18 June 1450, 1 July 1450 (the fight at Sevenoaks to the arrival) | 33 km | 13 | 2.5 |
The dates are as the place pages give them. For the Southwark to Iden’s garden leg, the last place is the village of Hothfield, which is one of several claims for where Cade was wounded on 12 July 1450, so that distance changes if another claim is right. The legs I left out are the ones that join two events with months or years between them, such as Shrewsbury and Gaultree Forest (nearly two years) and Flint Castle and Pontefract (six months), where the interval says nothing about travel.
This is a count of the record, not of the plays. The site does not record how long a play takes to move between two places, because I did not read the plays, so it cannot say whether a play moves faster or slower than the record did. What it can say is where the pages already note a difference, as on the France and Edward III pages, where the order of the headings and the order of the dates disagree.
How this was made, and what it leaves out
- What is counted. The same 124 play-place pairs as Patterns: places pinned on the play maps, without the reference points flagged ‘Not in the play’. Two plays count as sharing a place only if their maps pin it, and a play whose maps leave out a place it names will seem to share less than it does.
- The sorting. The kinds of play are the ones on Patterns, and they are mine.
- Collected by hand. Two parts are not made from the data: the list of maps whose places are numbered in heading order, and the list of dated legs with their dates. Both are in
tools/genmovement.py, and the legs are the ones I could find a single force and two exact dates for on the pages. - Straight lines. Every distance is a straight line on the globe between the maps’ points. A point stands for a place as its page says, and a sea crossing or a detour is not counted.
- No tests. The groups and routes are counts, and the pace table has seven legs. I do not offer a significance test.
- Remaking it.
python3 tools/genmovement.py <site folder>rewrites the figures and the numbers fromdata/*.geojson. If a map gains or loses a place, run it again and check this text against the new numbers.
The figures are drawn from the site’s own data; no map is used.