Macbeth’s Scotland · no. 9

Pitgaveny

Where the record, not the play, puts the death of Duncan: killed in battle with Macbeth, near Elgin, in 1040.

Real place Position: Uncertain
Pitgaveny and the Moray Firth, from map data Outline of the coast of the Moray Firth with the marker at Pitgaveny and rings at Inverness, Forres and Cawdor. A scale bar marks 20 km. A small map in one corner shows where the frame lies in the larger area. Moray Firth Inverness Forres Cawdor Pitgaveny 20 km N Scotland
Drawn from map data Pitgaveny and the Moray Firth. Today’s coastline from Natural Earth at a coarse scale, not that of the play’s time or of the events. The filled marker is a position I set by hand near Elgin, at the place that gives the battle its name; the battle’s exact ground is not given in what I read, and this point is not in the play. The rings are the other three places on this firth that have pages. The small map in the corner shows where this frame lies in the larger area.1
Dates
Battle fought 14 August 1040
Where
Pitgaveny, near Elgin, Moray
Position
57.6800° N, 3.3300° W. Set by hand at the place called Pitgaveny, near Elgin, and checked against the coast. The battle is named after the place and its exact ground is not given in what I read. This point is not in the play.2
Plays
Not in the play

What the plays say

This place is not in the play. The play puts the death of Duncan at Macbeth’s castle at Inverness, not at a battle in Moray.3

What the documents and the ground show

The record puts Duncan’s death at a battle on 14 August 1040 between him and Macbeth, then ruler of Moray, at Bothganown, now Pitgaveny, near Elgin.4 Macbeth had been Mormaer of Moray since 1032 and became king in 1040.5 The point is uncertain: I set it by hand at the place called Pitgaveny and checked it against the coast, and the ground of the battle is not given in what I read.6

Tradition, inference and open questions

It is on the map as a point of reference: it shows how far the play moves the killing, from a battle near Elgin to a castle at Inverness. A chapter on the historical Macbeth describes a successful reign, which the play does not.7

Open questions: the exact ground, and what Shakespeare and Holinshed knew of it.

Notes

  1. Natural Earth, 1:50m physical and cultural vector data (land, lakes, land boundary lines) and populated places, in the public domain, via github.com/nvkelso/natural-earth-vector; fetched 12 November 2026, coastline. Source ↓ ↩
  2. Natural Earth. Source ↓ ↩
  3. The Complete Works of William Shakespeare (MIT), Macbeth, scene index, scene headings. Source ↓ ↩
  4. Wikipedia, ‘Battle of Pitgaveny’, the battle. Source ↓ ↩
  5. Wikipedia, ‘Macbeth, King of Scotland’, the reign. Source ↓ ↩
  6. Natural Earth, coastline. Source ↓ ↩
  7. Cowan, E. J., ‘The historical MacBeth’, in W. D. H. Sellar (ed.), Moray: Province and People (1993), pp. 117–142, the reign. Source ↓ ↩

Sources cited

  • Secondary · Reference Natural Earth, 1:50m physical and cultural vector data (land, lakes, land boundary lines) and populated places, in the public domain, via github.com/nvkelso/natural-earth-vector; fetched 12 November 2026 — terms of use (public domain) Public-domain map data. The coastlines and borders are today’s, at 1:50m, which is generalised: small islands and bays are lost. Venice, Athens, Milan, Florence, Vienna, Paris, Rome, Alexandria, London, Naples, Tunis, Antakya, Tarsus and Mytilene (Mitilini) are taken from its populated-places layer, at the position it gives for each city.
  • Secondary · Reference The Complete Works of William Shakespeare (MIT), Macbeth, scene index — see the index Only a search extract was read. A web edition. Only the scene index was read, in search extracts: its headings, which are an editor’s, include a camp near Forres, a heath near Forres, Forres (the palace), Inverness (Macbeth’s castle), England (before the king’s palace), Dunsinane (the castle) and country near Birnam wood.
  • Secondary · Wikipedia Wikipedia, ‘Battle of Pitgaveny’ — read the article Only a search extract was read. An open encyclopaedia. Only a search extract was read: the battle, also called Bothnagowan, was fought on 14 August 1040 between Duncan I and Macbeth, then ruler of Moray, at Bothganown, now Pitgaveny, near Elgin.
  • Secondary · Wikipedia Wikipedia, ‘Macbeth, King of Scotland’ — read the article Only a search extract was read. An open encyclopaedia. Only search extracts, from mirrors, were read: he was King of Scots from 1040 to 1057 and Mormaer of Moray from 1032; Duncan was killed at Bothnagowan, now Pitgaveny, near Elgin; Macbeth was killed at Lumphanan in 1057 by forces loyal to the future Malcolm III; he is said to have been buried on Iona; and evidence suggests he spent much time in and around Forres.
  • Scholarly Cowan, E. J., ‘The historical MacBeth’, in W. D. H. Sellar (ed.), Moray: Province and People (1993), pp. 117–142 — read the chapter Only a search extract was read. A scholarly chapter. Only a search extract was read, which describes Macbeth as a mormaer of Moray whose reign was remarkably successful and who came to be seen as the last great Celtic king of Scots.