London in Henry VI, Part 1 · no. 1

Temple Garden

Where the heading puts the scene in which the rival nobles pluck red and white roses. The scene is not in the record, and the garden is shared between two Inns of Court.

Real place Position: Approximate
Temple Garden: where it stands among the London sites A map of central London from Westminster to the Tower, with the Thames, today's main roads and a dot for each place on the London maps. This page's position is ringed. A scale bar marks 1 kilometre. WhitefriarsPriorySt Paul’s N 1 km England Ireland France
Drawn from map data Temple Garden: where it stands among the London sites. Today’s river and main roads from OpenStreetMap, with the places of the London maps as dots and this page’s position ringed, in one frame about 4.9 km across that is the same on every London page. The ring shows how sure the position is, as on the maps: plain means an approximate position. The river is today’s embanked course and the streets are today’s; the Fleet, the City wall, the lanes and the buildings of the time are not drawn, and the ring marks a position, not a footprint. The small map in the corner shows where this frame lies in the larger area.12
Dates
Scene not in the record; the Temple, from the 12th century
Where
The Temple, between Fleet Street and the Thames, City of London
Position
51.5119° N, 0.1111° W. The position Wikipedia gives for the Temple (51°30′43″N 0°06′40″W). It stands for the precinct that now holds the Inner and Middle Temple, not for either Inn’s garden. Historic England’s position for the Inner Temple Garden is, by my arithmetic, about 100 metres to the east.3
Plays
Henry VI, Part 1

What the play says

The Gutenberg and MIT headings put the second scene of the second act in ‘London. The Temple Garden’.456 It is the scene in which, in the sources’ telling, Richard Plantagenet and a Somerset quarrel and the nobles present pluck white and red roses to show their side. The sources do not agree which Beaufort the Somerset is: the Inner Temple’s history says John Beaufort,7 and a history magazine’s blog says Edmund Beaufort.8 I did not read the play, so I cannot say which it names.

What the documents and the ground show

The Temple was the precinct of the Knights Templar,9 whose round church was consecrated in 1185, with its aisled chancel following in 1240.10 By the middle of the fifteenth century the buildings and gardens had been separated into the Middle and Inner Temple, although the formal division did not come until 1732.11 The Inner Temple’s records describe an orchard, mention its roses by the fourteenth century,12 and name a first gardener in 1307.13

Today both gardens show red and white roses that are said to mark the place of the plucking: beds on the Inner Temple’s Terrace and three large beds in the Middle Temple Garden.1415 New white and red roses were planted in the modern gardens in 2002.16

The point is approximate. It is the position Wikipedia gives for the Temple as a whole, not for a garden,17 because the play’s heading does not say which Inn’s garden is meant, and both Inns’ gardens now claim the roses. Historic England’s position for the Inner Temple Garden is a little to the east.18

Tradition, inference and open questions

The scene is not in the record. Wikipedia calls it fictional,19 and the Inner Temple’s library says the story has not been corroborated by contemporary evidence.20 The roses themselves are later than the quarrel it shows: the red rose was not widely adopted by the Lancastrians before 1485,21 and the name ‘Wars of the Roses’ came into common use only after Scott’s novel of 1829, which took it, Wikipedia says, from this scene.22

Open questions: which Beaufort the play’s Somerset is, where in the Temple the scene is imagined, and whether either Inn’s garden has a better claim to it. Westminster Abbey and the Tower, the other places the headings name, are on the map of Richard III’s London.

Notes

  1. OpenStreetMap contributors, map data for central London, exported with Overpass Turbo on 12 November 2026 (base layer; landmarks, 10:04 UTC). Open Database Licence (ODbL), the river and roads. Source ↓ ↩
  2. Wikipedia, ‘Temple, London’, the position. Source ↓ ↩
  3. Wikipedia, Temple, London. Source ↓ ↩
  4. King Henry VI, Part 1, Project Gutenberg ebook 1500 (the contents), contents and scene headings. Source ↓ ↩
  5. The First Part of King Henry the Sixth, The Complete Works of William Shakespeare (MIT), contents, contents and scene headings. Source ↓ ↩
  6. The First Part of Henry the Sixth, Unotate edition (scene list), the scene list. Source ↓ ↩
  7. The Inner Temple, ‘History of the Garden’, the history of the garden. Source ↓ ↩
  8. C. A. Lloyd, ‘The Red Rose and the White: The Story Behind the Tudor Rose’, The Historians Magazine, the Temple Garden. Source ↓ ↩
  9. Wikipedia, Temple, London, coordinates and the name. Source ↓ ↩
  10. British Listed Buildings, ‘Temple Church (St Mary’s)’ (Historic England listing, Grade I), the listing. Source ↓ ↩
  11. Historic England, Register of Parks and Gardens, ‘Inner Temple’ (inventory of gardens, via Institut Européen des Jardins & Paysages), the inventory entry. Source ↓ ↩
  12. Inner Temple, history of the garden, the history of the garden. Source ↓ ↩
  13. The Inner Temple, ‘History of the Garden’ (archives note), the archives note. Source ↓ ↩
  14. Parks & Gardens UK, ‘Inner Temple’, the rose beds. Source ↓ ↩
  15. Parks & Gardens UK, ‘Middle Temple’, the rose beds. Source ↓ ↩
  16. Wikipedia, ‘Temple Church’, the church and the scene. Source ↓ ↩
  17. Wikipedia, Temple, London, coordinates and the name. Source ↓ ↩
  18. Historic England, Inner Temple garden, the inventory entry. Source ↓ ↩
  19. Wikipedia, Temple Church, the church and the scene. Source ↓ ↩
  20. Inner Temple Library, ‘The Gardens’ (history of the Inner Temple), the gardens. Source ↓ ↩
  21. History (history.co.uk), ‘5 little known facts about the Wars of the Roses’, the roses. Source ↓ ↩
  22. Wikipedia, ‘Wars of the Roses’ (name and symbols), the name. Source ↓ ↩

Sources cited

  • Secondary · Reference OpenStreetMap contributors, map data for central London, exported with Overpass Turbo on 12 November 2026 (base layer; landmarks, 10:04 UTC). Open Database Licence (ODbL) — licence and credit A map made by volunteers. The landmark positions were copied unchanged from the export, which was read in full; each is the centre of a mapped building, bridge or outline, or a station point, so it can sit tens of metres from the feature’s door or the middle of its span. Not checked against another source. It maps today’s streets and buildings, which is all the landmarks are used for.
  • Secondary · Wikipedia Wikipedia, ‘Temple, London’ — coordinates and the name Only a search extract was read. Only a search extract from a mirror of the article was seen. It gives the coordinates of the Temple as 51°30′43″N 0°06′40″W, says the name is shared with Inner Temple, Middle Temple, Temple Church and Temple Bar, and says the Temple was originally the precinct of the Knights Templar.
  • Secondary · Reference King Henry VI, Part 1, Project Gutenberg ebook 1500 (the contents) — contents and scene headings Only a search extract was read. A public-domain etext. Only search extracts of the contents were seen, not the play. They give Act 1 scene 2 as France, before Orleans; Act 2 scene 3 as Auvergne, the Countess’s castle; Act 3 as France before Rouen, the plains near Rouen and Paris, the palace; Act 4 as Paris, the palace, before Bordeaux, plains in Gascony, the English camp near Bordeaux and two scenes of a field of battle; and Act 5 as France, plains in Anjou, and before Angiers. A messenger’s opening list of towns reported lost includes Rouen, Orleans and Paris. The extracts also head Act 1 scene 1 ‘Westminster Abbey’ and scene 3 ‘London. Before the Tower’; Act 2 scene 4 ‘London. The Temple Garden’ and scene 5 ‘The Tower of London’; Act 3 scene 1 ‘London. The Parliament House’; and Act 5 scene 1 ‘London. The Palace’.
  • Secondary · Reference The First Part of King Henry the Sixth, The Complete Works of William Shakespeare (MIT), contents — contents and scene headings Only a search extract was read. An online edition. Only a search extract of the contents was seen, not the play. It gives Act 3 scene 2 as France, before Rouen, scene 3 as the plains near Rouen and scene 4 as Paris, the palace; and Act 4 scene 1 as Paris, a hall of state, scene 2 as before Bordeaux (spelled Bourdeaux) and scene 3 as plains in Gascony. A second extract gives Act 2 scene 4 as ‘London. The Temple-garden’, scene 5 as ‘The Tower of London’, Act 3 scene 1 as ‘London. The Parliament-house’, and Act 5 scenes 1 and 5 as ‘London. The palace’.
  • Secondary · Reference The First Part of Henry the Sixth, Unotate edition (scene list) — the scene list Only a search extract was read. Only a search extract was seen. It heads Act 1 scene 1 ‘Westminster Abbey’ and scene 3 ‘London. Before the Tower’; Act 2 scene 4 ‘London. The temple garden’ and scene 5 ‘London. A room in the Tower of London’; and Act 3 scene 1 ‘London. The Parliament House’. The headings are an editor’s, not the play’s.
  • Secondary · Reference The Inner Temple, ‘History of the Garden’ — the history of the garden Only a search extract was read. Only a search extract was seen. It says the medieval records describe an orchard, that by the 14th century there are several mentions of its roses, and that Shakespeare used it as the setting for the meeting between Richard Plantagenet and John Beaufort which sparked the Wars of the Roses.
  • Secondary · Blog C. A. Lloyd, ‘The Red Rose and the White: The Story Behind the Tudor Rose’, The Historians Magazine — the Temple Garden Only a search extract was read. Only a search extract was seen. It says the tension in the play between Edmund Beaufort, Duke of Somerset, and Richard Plantagenet erupts in the Temple Garden. Another source seen names Somerset in the scene as John Beaufort.
  • Secondary · Reference British Listed Buildings, ‘Temple Church (St Mary’s)’ (Historic England listing, Grade I) — the listing Only a search extract was read. Only search extracts were seen. They reproduce the Grade I listing: a circular, aisled nave consecrated in 1185 and an aisled chancel consecrated in 1240, in Inner Temple Lane, at latitude 51.5133, longitude −0.1102 (TQ312810).
  • Secondary · Reference Historic England, Register of Parks and Gardens, ‘Inner Temple’ (inventory of gardens, via Institut Européen des Jardins & Paysages) — the inventory entry Only a search extract was read. Only search extracts were seen. They give a position for the Inner Temple of latitude 51.511784, longitude −0.10961656 (TQ 31278 80900); describe the garden as about 1.5 hectares, south of Fleet Street, north of the Thames and east of Middle Temple; and say the Temple’s buildings and gardens had been separated into Middle and Inner Temple by the mid 15th century, though the formal division did not come until 1732.
  • Secondary · Reference The Inner Temple, ‘History of the Garden’ (archives note) — the archives note Only a search extract was read. Only a search extract was seen. It says the Inn’s archives record the first gardener of the Inn as appointed in 1307.
  • Secondary · Reference Parks & Gardens UK, ‘Inner Temple’ — the rose beds Only a search extract was read. Only a search extract was seen. It says the lawn on the Terrace is set out with beds of roses, mostly red and white, which traditionally mark the place where the emblems of the Wars of the Roses were plucked.
  • Secondary · Reference Parks & Gardens UK, ‘Middle Temple’ — the rose beds Only a search extract was read. Only a search extract was seen. It says there are three large rectangular rose beds on the lawn, planted with red and white roses, and that traditionally the white rose of York and the red rose of Lancaster were plucked in the Temple Garden.
  • Secondary · Wikipedia Wikipedia, ‘Temple Church’ — the church and the scene Only a search extract was read. Only search extracts were seen. They say the church serves both the Inner and Middle Temple as a private chapel, that Shakespeare knew the site and that the church and garden feature in Henry VI, Part 1 as the setting for the fictional scene of the plucking of two roses, and that in 2002 an event was commemorated by planting new white and red roses in the modern gardens.
  • Secondary · Reference Inner Temple Library, ‘The Gardens’ (history of the Inner Temple) — the gardens Only a search extract was read. Only a search extract was seen. It says the gardens were known for their fine rose-bushes and that, according to Shakespeare, whose story has not yet been corroborated by contemporary evidence, the Wars of the Roses began there.
  • Secondary · Reference History (history.co.uk), ‘5 little known facts about the Wars of the Roses’ — the roses Only a search extract was read. Only a search extract was seen. It says the red rose had not been widely adopted by the Lancastrians before 1485, that the popular belief to the contrary eventually inspired the name, that the name was popularised by Walter Scott, and that the conflict was earlier commonly called the Cousins’ War.
  • Secondary · Wikipedia Wikipedia, ‘Wars of the Roses’ (name and symbols) — the name Only a search extract was read. Only search extracts from mirrors of the article were seen. They say the modern term came into common use in the early 19th century after Walter Scott’s novel Anne of Geierstein (1829), and that Scott based the name on a scene in Henry VI, Part 1 (Act 2 scene 4), set in the gardens of the Temple Church, where noblemen and a lawyer pick red or white roses; one mirror’s caption calls the scene historically apocryphal.