The Two Noble Kinsmen · no. 1

Thebes

Where the headings put the court of the palace and a field before the city in the first act. The rest of the play is in Athens and its neighbourhood.

Real place Position: Approximate
Emblem: a town or city A town or city drawn inside a ring with compass ticks and a north mark; the ring is plain. N
Illustration only Emblem: a town or city. A town or city, drawn as an emblem for this kind of place, not as a drawing of this one. The ring shows how sure the position is, in the same three steps as the markers on the maps: plain means an approximate position. The kind is my shorthand from the page’s name and summary, and the compass ticks only echo the maps. Nothing here records the place.
Dates
Play first produced about 1612 to 1613
Where
Thebes (Thiva), Boeotia
Position
38.3208° N, 23.3178° E. The position Wikipedia gives for the modern city of Thebes (Thiva), which is built over the ancient city. It stands for the city: Wikivoyage’s position for the Cadmea, the ancient citadel, is under 200 metres from it.1
Plays
The Two Noble Kinsmen

What the plays say

One edition gives the scene of The Two Noble Kinsmen as Athens and the neighbourhood, except in part of the first act, where it is Thebes and the neighbourhood.2 The editors’ headings put two scenes of Act 1 in or at Thebes, the court of the palace and a field before the city, and a third in another part of the same field, more remote from Thebes.3 A synopsis says the two cousins, Palamon and Arcite, discuss leaving Thebes because their uncle Creon’s reign has corrupted the state, and on news that Theseus is advancing on the city go to its defence.4 The play begins, by the same synopsis, as Athens defeats Thebes in war, and the two knights end up imprisoned in Athens,5 so after the first act the play does not return to Thebes in the headings I saw.

The headings are an editor’s, not the play’s. I did not read the play for this entry and I do not reproduce its text.

What the documents and the ground show

Thebes is a real city in Boeotia, in Central Greece, and one of the oldest continuously inhabited cities in the world. The modern city, Thiva, has an archaeological museum, the remains of the Cadmea, which was the citadel from the Bronze Age on, and scattered ancient remains.6 The point on the map is approximate: it is Wikipedia’s position for the modern city, 38.32083° N, 23.31778° E.7 Wikivoyage gives a position for the Cadmea, which it says lies beneath the modern town, that is under 200 metres away on my arithmetic, so the marker stands for the city and not for any one building.8

Taking the two positions I use, Thebes is about 52 kilometres north-west of Athens in a straight line. That is my calculation from the map’s own points, not a figure from a source, and the play gives no distance.

The same guide says ancient Thebes dominated classical Greece in the fourth century BC and was destroyed by Alexander in 335 BC.9 That is the real city’s history. The war in the play, between Theseus and the tyrant Creon, belongs to the story Chaucer retold and not to any record I have found of the city.

Tradition, inference and open questions

The play’s plot derives from Chaucer’s “Knight’s Tale”, which itself shortened Boccaccio’s Teseida.10 In Boccaccio, as a summary has it, Teseo turns his army to Thebes, fights Creon and wins, and his soldiers then find two cousins nearly dead on the field.11 A summary of Chaucer has Theseus defeat Creon, the tyrannical ruler of Thebes, and send the two cousins to prison in Athens; and it ends with Palamon married and ruler of Thebes, his homeland.12 Whether the play keeps that ending is not something I checked, because I did not read it.

The Thebes of the play is the Thebes of a story set in antiquity;13 a pin at the modern city is a convenience, and says only where the name belongs on a map. The play’s Athens has its own entry, Athens and the wood, made for A Midsummer Night’s Dream, and the series page links to it and does not pin the city again.

Open questions: how the play’s first audience pictured Thebes, and where, if anywhere, its field before the city was meant to lie.

Notes

  1. Wikipedia, ‘Thebes, Greece’. Source ↓ ↩
  2. The Two Noble Kinsmen, Standard Ebooks edition (scene note and Act 1 heading), scene note. Source ↓ ↩
  3. The Two Noble Kinsmen, Project Gutenberg ebook 1506 (the contents), scene headings. Source ↓ ↩
  4. Folger Shakespeare Library, The Two Noble Kinsmen, synopsis (Folger Digital Texts), Act 1 scene 2. Source ↓ ↩
  5. Folger Digital Texts, Kinsmen synopsis, the opening. Source ↓ ↩
  6. Wikipedia, Thebes, Greece, the city today. Source ↓ ↩
  7. Wikipedia, Thebes, Greece, coordinates. Source ↓ ↩
  8. Wikivoyage, ‘Thebes, Greece’, the Cadmea. Source ↓ ↩
  9. Wikivoyage, Thebes, history. Source ↓ ↩
  10. Wikipedia, ‘The Two Noble Kinsmen’, sources. Source ↓ ↩
  11. Wikipedia, ‘Teseida’, the battle. Source ↓ ↩
  12. O. Tearle, ‘A Summary and Analysis of Geoffrey Chaucer’s “The Knight’s Tale”’, Interesting Literature, 2021, the tale. Source ↓ ↩
  13. EBSCO Research Starters, The Two Noble Kinsmen: analysis of setting, time of the work. Source ↓ ↩

Sources cited

  • Secondary · Wikipedia Wikipedia, ‘Thebes, Greece’ — coordinates and the city today Only a search extract was read. Only search extracts were seen. They give the coordinates of Thebes (Thiva) as 38°19′15″N 23°19′04″E (38.32083, 23.31778), in the regional unit of Boeotia, and describe it as a city in Boeotia, Central Greece, and one of the oldest continuously inhabited cities in the world. They say the modern city contains an archaeological museum, the remains of the Cadmea, a citadel of the Bronze Age and later, and scattered ancient remains.
  • Secondary · Reference The Two Noble Kinsmen, Standard Ebooks edition (scene note and Act 1 heading) — scene note Only a search extract was read. Only a search extract was seen, not the play. It gives the edition’s note on the scene, Athens and the neighbourhood, except in part of the first act, where it is Thebes and the neighbourhood, and heads the first scene ‘Athens. Before a temple’.
  • Secondary · Reference The Two Noble Kinsmen, Project Gutenberg ebook 1506 (the contents) — contents and scene headings Only a search extract was read. A public-domain etext. Only the contents were seen, in search extracts, not the play. They head Act 1 ‘Athens. Before a temple’, ‘Thebes. The Court of the Palace’, ‘Before the gates of Athens’, ‘A field before Thebes’ and ‘Another part of the same, more remote from Thebes’; Act 2 ‘Athens. A garden, with a castle in the background’, ‘The prison’, ‘The country near Athens’, a room in the prison, ‘An open place in Athens’ and ‘Athens. Before the prison’; Act 3 two scenes in a forest near Athens; and, at the end, ‘A part of the Forest near Athens, and near the Place appointed for the Combat’ and ‘The same; a Block prepared’. The headings are an editor’s, not the play’s.
  • Secondary · Reference Folger Shakespeare Library, The Two Noble Kinsmen, synopsis (Folger Digital Texts) — synopsis The page was fetched and I read a tool-generated summary of it, not the full text. The synopsis was fetched and I read a tool-generated summary of it, not the page; earlier I had only a search extract. It runs scene by scene from Theseus’s wedding procession to Arcite’s death after his horse falls and Palamon’s marriage to Emilia. A search extract also says the play begins as Athens defeats Thebes in war, with the Theban knights Arcite and Palamon imprisoned in Athens; and that in Act 1 scene 2 the two cousins discuss leaving Thebes, where their uncle Creon’s reign has corrupted the state, and on news of Theseus’s advance on Thebes go to its defence.
  • Secondary · Reference Wikivoyage, ‘Thebes, Greece’ — the Cadmea Only a search extract was read. Only a search extract was seen. It says the modern town is built on the site of the ancient city, which dominated classical Greece in the 4th century BC until Alexander destroyed it in 335 BC, and gives a position for the Cadmea of 38.319444, 23.316667, saying the ancient citadel lies beneath the modern town.
  • Secondary · Wikipedia Wikipedia, ‘The Two Noble Kinsmen’ — sources and attribution Only a search extract was read. Only search extracts were seen. They say the play was published in 1634 and is attributed to John Fletcher and William Shakespeare, that its plot derives from Chaucer’s “Knight’s Tale”, which itself shortened Boccaccio’s Teseida, and that the tale had been staged at least twice before, though both versions are lost.
  • Secondary · Wikipedia Wikipedia, ‘Teseida’ — Boccaccio’s poem Only a search extract was read. Only a search extract was seen. It calls the poem the main source of Chaucer’s “Knight’s Tale” and so the original source of the play, and says Teseo turns his army to Thebes, fights Creon and wins, and his soldiers then find two cousins nearly dead on the field.
  • Secondary · Blog O. Tearle, ‘A Summary and Analysis of Geoffrey Chaucer’s “The Knight’s Tale”’, Interesting Literature, 2021 — the tale Only a search extract was read. Only a search extract was seen. It says that on his return Theseus defeats Creon, the tyrannical ruler of Thebes; that two men, Creon’s nephews Palamon and Arcite, are found alive under a pile of corpses and sent to prison in Athens; and that Palamon and Emelye marry, with Palamon becoming ruler of Thebes, his homeland. It is a summary of Chaucer, not of the play.
  • Secondary · Reference EBSCO Research Starters, The Two Noble Kinsmen: analysis of setting — the setting Only a search extract was read. A reference summary. Only a search extract was seen. It says the play unfolds mainly in Athens and Thebes, gives its first production as about 1612 to 1613 and its time as antiquity, and says Athens is the backdrop for much of it.